IRMA HOTEL

By Eric from Seattle • What a DUMP!

Overall Rating: 2   

This place is a sad example of when bad things happen to good places. I just spent an unfortunate evening at the Irma with three friends and was less than pleased with the experience.

First, we stayed in the "modern" section of the hotel, which from appearances dates from the 30's. The room itself had a melange of styles--dingy shag carpet that would have been appropriate in a... [more] Mexican restaurant, tobacco-stained floral bedspreads and faded art on the the wall. The ceiling fan was CAKED with dust and to top it all off there were no windows. I have no idea how the air conditioner that was hanging crookedly on the wall was supposed to cool us down--it had no place to empty its' warm exhaust. Needless to say, we spent a stuffy, asthma-cough filled night.

The staff were also underwhelming. I don't expect to be treated with surly diffidence when I travel, especially in a community that prides itself on being the "Gateway to Yellowstone". I called once to confirm my reservation and was hung up on 3 times. Our wakeup call also came early by an hour. Finally, I felt gouged not only by springs in the Jello-like mattress but also the price--a "bargain at $115. I've paid the same for four-star accomodations throughout the US (granted, they were on special).

This place cries out for a thorough cleaning and restoration. Its bar is impressive but was cheapened by the overall decay exhibited throughout the rest of the establishment. Buffalo Bill would be embarassed to be associated with the Irma, his daughters namesake.

Though I am always keen on supporting local establishments, stick with the better known chains--eg. Holiday Inn and Super 8--when staying in Cody. What they lack in charm they make up for in consistency and cleanliness.

In sum--I am a former Montana resident who has roots four-generations back in the area. I'm not some persnickety sissy or big-city tenderfoot. This really was beyond the pale--I've never seen a place in such a need of a makeover. Until you see that the Irma has been EXTENSIVELY renovated, avoid staying there at all costs. [less]
Was this review helpful to you? → YES / NO

By • Never again!

Overall Rating: 2   Location [6] • Room [2] • Service [4] • Value [2]

I totally hated this so called "hotel." First of all, there aren't any elevators at all; our bags had to be carried up the stairs! The hallways smell like greasy food and the beds are small and squeak at every little movement. We didn't even enter the restuarant as it was so smokey.
Was this review helpful to you? → YES / NO

By Trip Tutorial User from Cody, Wyoming • Saddened and disappointed!

Overall Rating: 2   Location [10] • Room [2] • Service [2] • Value [4]

I was born and raised in Cody, Wyoming, and, in the past, loved to eat at the Irma Hotel Restaurant and Silver Saddle Bar.

I was so saddened and disappointed on our last visit to Cody and the Irma, since being away for several years.

The service was just horrible, waitresses downright smartass and dumpy, like they couldn't give a lick to give you decent service! ... [more]The food was also tasteless, and so lacking in any sort of desireable presentation.

We also noticed, as we walked through the lobby and restaurant of the Irma, how dirty, dusty, and not kept up, as a historic hotel like this should be.

It's a heartbreaker to see such a great landmark hotel such as the Irma, being run into the ground.
We hope, in the future, and none too soon, someone will take over this historic hotel built by Buffalo Bill Cody, see it for it's unique beauty and "specialness," and bring it up to the high standard it deserves.

Cody is a great little town, with so much history. It deserves the best, and so does one of the great legacies of Buffalo Bill...The Irma Hotel! [less]
Was this review helpful to you? → YES / NO